false
Category
Author
Search for Articles
Trending Keywords
Category
Author
Search
Category
Author
Search
Savings and Investment
Editor's Pick

How can transparency around investment-linked insurance charges be improved?

2021-09-29 5min read
How-to-Improve-ILAS-Fee-Disclosure-kv.png
As mentioned in an earlier article, if the benefit illustration for an investment-linked assurance scheme (ILAS) discloses the expected surrender value under loss scenarios, this would help manage consumers’ expectations. In addition, if the relevant document included a new column showing the “actual charges and fees” of the ILAS under different scenarios, policyholders would be able to understand the product’s charges more clearly.
 
According to the Guideline on Benefit Illustrations for Long Term Insurance Policies (Guideline 28) (Note 1) issued by the Insurance Authority, the benefit illustration should be prepared to reflect all policy-level fees and charges (excluding fund management fees). However, although the relevant fees and charges are reflected in the expected surrender value and death benefit, they are not separately disclosed in an independent column. This makes it difficult for policyholders to understand exactly how much the insurer has charged under the assumed policy term and returns.
 
Adding an actual charges column to enhance policyholders’ understanding
 
The writer uses AIA’s 「卓達智悅」 ILAS as an example. Assuming a 40-year-old male makes a single premium investment of HK$1 million, in addition to the expected surrender values in the 20th year under annual returns of 0% and 3% as set out in the benefit illustration, the writer asked the 10Life actuarial team to estimate the expected surrender value for the relevant policy term under an annual loss scenario of 3%.
 
This expected surrender value includes fees and charges. To identify the specific fees and charges of the above ILAS, the writer asked the 10Life actuarial team to calculate the expected surrender value in the 20th year under different return scenarios after excluding fees and charges. By subtracting one figure from the other, the specific amount of fees and charges can be shown independently and clearly. (See the chart below.)
 
Figure 1: Expected surrender values of the above ILAS under different return scenarios (with and without fees and charges) 
 

 
 
Notes:
  1. The above ILAS benefit illustration assumes that the insured is a 40-year-old male, with a single premium of HK$1 million and the policy being in its 20th policy year. The expected surrender values shown are calculated based on net rates of return. Using a return of 3% as an example, the 10Life actuarial team simulated a maximum TFCD percentage of 24.27%, which differs slightly from the 24% stated in the product key facts statement;
  2. The net rate of return is calculated after deducting the fees and charges of the reference fund imposed by the fund company. Such fund fees and charges vary depending on the reference fund;
  3. 10Life collected publicly available information from insurers through different channels, including product key facts statements and benefit illustrations, and calculated the above figures based on the most accurate information available. The figures are for reference only, do not take your personal needs into account and absolutely do not constitute sales advice. Before taking out a policy, users should consult a licensed insurance adviser;
  4. The above information was updated on 16 September 2021.
According to the above chart, taking an annual return of 3% as an example, the expected surrender value in the 20th year is HK$1.45 million. Assuming fees and charges are excluded, the expected surrender value would be HK$1.87 million, representing a difference of as much as HK$420,000 (see Figure 1).
 
Under the annual loss scenario of 3%, the expected surrender value in the 20th year is only HK$430,000. After excluding fees and charges, the remaining amount would be HK$570,000, meaning that, in addition to the loss, fees and charges would further erode approximately HK$140,000. If these specific fees could be clearly listed separately in the benefit illustration, this would help policyholders gain a better understanding of the product.
 
Last month, the writer contacted the Insurance Authority to ask whether a new column should be added to the benefit illustration, showing the actual fees and charges of the ILAS under different policy terms and assumed returns, so that policyholders could understand the product’s actual position more clearly.
 
In its reply, the Insurance Authority stated that it had consistently sought to strike a balance between enhancing transparency and avoiding the provision of excessive information to general customers, with a view to promoting the healthy and sustainable development of the insurance industry. It would review the existing regulatory regime from time to time to ensure that it kept pace with international regulatory standards and industry developments.
 
TFCD formula not disclosed in product key facts statements
 
The Securities and Futures Commission enhanced the disclosure requirements for ILAS in 2013 and introduced the total fees and charges disclosure (TFCD) requirement (Note 2). The product key facts statement (KFS) must state the percentage of the total premium paid that represents fees and charges paid to the insurer (the TFCD percentage), making it easier for consumers to identify ILAS charges. However, a number of problems remain:

 
  • The TFCD percentage formula is rather complicated (Note 3). Whether an insurer adopts an upfront-charge or deferred-charge model will affect the relevant percentage, meaning that it may not reflect the actual charging structure;
  • The comparability of TFCD percentages is limited. For example, the underlying assumptions for single-premium and regular-premium ILAS products are already different: the former involves paying the premium in one lump sum and holding the policy for 20 years, whereas the latter involves paying premiums by instalments over a longer period;
  • In some cases, most individual charges for “Product A” are lower than those for “Product B”, yet its TFCD percentage is higher;
  • The TFCD percentage reflects only policy-level charges and does not reflect fund-level charges;
  • ILAS products have numerous individual charges, such as administration fees, portfolio management fees and withdrawal fees. Their names are not standardised, making it difficult for consumers to compare them.
 
10Life recommends improving disclosure in benefit illustrations
According to media reports, the Insurance Authority is discussing with the industry the development of ILAS products with higher protection. The death benefit is expected to be 150% of the policy value. These products are known as Protection-Linked Plans (PLPs), and guidelines are currently being drafted for consultation.
 
The writer welcomes any measures by the Insurance Authority that help enhance consumer protection, and also recommends that the authority take this opportunity to improve the disclosure requirements for ILAS:
 
  • A loss scenario should be added to the benefit illustration, enabling policyholders to understand the potential risk of loss clearly and manage their expectations more effectively;
  • The actual fees and charges arising from an ILAS under different policy years and assumed returns should be clearly stated in the benefit illustration and presented in a separate column to enhance product transparency;
  • For each ILAS product, the insurer issuing the product should disclose the TFCD formula in detail in the product key facts statement to enhance transparency;
  • The names of individual fees and charges in product key facts statements should be standardised to avoid consumer confusion, make comparisons easier and reduce misunderstandings.
Notes:
  1. Guideline on Benefit Illustrations for Long Term Insurance Policies;
  2. The Securities and Futures Commission’s updated ILAS disclosure requirements in 2013;
  3. The TFCD formula set out in the Investor and Financial Education Council’s Total Fees and Charges Disclosure. 

This English version of this article has been generated by machine translation powered by AI. It is provided solely for reference purposes. In the event of any discrepancy or inconsistency between this translation and the original Chinese version, the Chinese version shall prevail.

10Life Logo
10Life Editorial Team

Our team of professional content researchers focussing on insurance

10Life Logo
10Life Editorial Team

Our team of professional content researchers focussing on insurance

Disclaimer

10Life Product Comparison and 10Life Insurance Ratings are developed by 10Life Financial Limited, an authorised insurance broker company licensed with the Insurance Authority under License Number FB1526. 10Life Product Comparison and 10Life Insurance Ratings are developed for generic customer segments using mathematical calculations based on product information, facts and data, and are not influenced by any partnerships with or fees received from insurance companies. Any information on 10Life Platform ("10Life Information"), including but not limited to Product Comparison, Product Ratings, Blog Articles are intended for general education purpose and reference only. None of the 10Life Information is intended, nor should they be considered or relied upon, as regulated advice, insurance, financial, investment or professional advice, recommendation, approval, endorsement, invitation or solicitation in respect of any insurance, financial or investment products. 10Life Information does not take into account your individual needs. Reading 10Life Information should not be considered as conducting a suitability assessment, and is not sufficient to form the basis of any decisions to purchase any insurance products. You should rely on information authorised by insurance companies, carry out your own research and/or seek independent advice from licensed intermediaries before purchasing any insurance products or making any insurance decisions. While reasonable effort is used when collecting, validating and updating 10Life Information from various channels, none of 10Life Group and its subsidiaries, affiliates, agents, directors, officers and employees will be responsible for any liability, claim or loss arising from or associated with you using 10Life Information. No warranty, representation or guarantee is given by 10Life Group and its subsidiaries on the accuracy, completeness and timeliness of the information. If you have any questions on 10Life Product Comparison and 10Life Insurance Ratings, please email us at enquiries@10life.com

Whatsapp icon
Whatsapp icon
WeChat icon
WeChat icon
Enquiry icon Close icon
Back To Top
Whatsapp icon
Whatsapp icon
WhatsApp