false
Category
Author
Search for Articles
Trending Keywords
Category
Author
Search
Category
Author
Search
編輯推介

Traditional medical insurance offers insufficient coverage. Cancer insurance enhances protection against cancer. Pay attention to 4 key considerations.

2022-06-27 9min read
Cancer-Medical-Insurance-Comparison.png
Cancer is a common cause of death among Hong Kong residents. In the unfortunate event of a diagnosis, patients may face exorbitant medical expenses and prolonged treatment. Many consumers purchased traditional medical insurance years ago, but the coverage may not be sufficient to cope with the continuously rising costs of cancer treatment driven by innovative technologies. For those who are still healthy, switching to emerging "full reimbursement" medical insurance plans could be an option, though the premiums are relatively high. Another way to enhance cancer protection is to retain the existing traditional medical insurance while additionally purchasing a specific Cancer Reimbursement policy to bolster cancer coverage. This approach is suitable for consumers with limited budgets who are concerned about the medical expenses related to cancer.

Comparing Traditional Medical Insurance and Cancer Medical Insurance

Traditional medical insurance covers hospitalisation expenses caused by injury or illness, often with a compensation limit for each specific item, which may not be sufficient to cover cancer treatment costs. On the other hand, cancer insurance typically sets a compensation limit per cancer diagnosis, reimbursing actual medical expenses incurred for cancer treatment on a more targeted basis.

Table 1: Comparison of Traditional Medical Insurance and Cancer Medical Insurance

DifferenceTraditional Medical InsuranceCancer Medical Insurance
Covered DiseasesMultiple diseases, including cancerCancer only
CoverageCompensation limits set for different sub-itemsReimbursement of actual medical expenses incurred for cancer treatment, subject to per cancer event limit and lifetime compensation limit
Waiting PeriodGenerally 30 days;
Voluntary Health Insurance Scheme has no waiting period
Generally 90 days, cancer symptoms or diagnoses during the waiting period are not covered

Medical Insurance Coverage Insufficient? Cancer Insurance Can Fill the Gap

Traditional medical insurance and cancer-specific medical insurance differ primarily in three aspects: covered conditions, compensation models, and waiting periods. Traditional medical insurance provides coverage for hospitalisation and day surgeries caused by injuries or illnesses. In contrast, cancer-specific medical insurance is limited to coverage for cancer only.


Moreover, the compensation models of the two types of insurance vary significantly. Traditional medical insurance often sets specific caps on individual items, such as a maximum daily reimbursement of HKD 500 for the attending doctor's ward visit fees. If the actual cost is HKD 900, the patient would need to pay the remaining HKD 400 out of pocket. On the other hand, cancer-specific medical insurance typically reimburses the actual medical expenses incurred due to cancer, subject to per-claim and lifetime compensation limits. Some cancer-specific plans even cover costs for purchasing or renting medical equipment, consulting dietitians, or receiving psychological counselling—expenses that are generally not covered under traditional medical insurance.


In terms of waiting periods, the duration for medical insurance depends on the type of plan, usually around 30 days, while some plans, such as Voluntary Health Insurance Schemes, have no waiting period. For cancer-specific medical insurance, the waiting period is generally 90 days, during which any cancer symptoms or diagnoses are not covered. It is important to note that even after the waiting period, if a claim is made within the first two years of the policy's effective date, insurance companies may scrutinise the claim rigorously due to the possibility of pre-existing conditions.


The advantages and disadvantages of cancer-specific medical insurance are relatively clear. If a consumer's existing medical insurance plan offers insufficient coverage and they have a limited budget but wish to enhance protection against cancer, adding a cancer-specific medical insurance plan could be a viable option. However, if a consumer does not have any other medical insurance and only purchases cancer-specific coverage, they would lack protection for other illnesses or procedures, such as angioplasty or joint replacement surgeries, which are common and costly medical cases.

When purchasing cancer-specific medical insurance, consumers should pay attention to the following four key points to avoid unexpected disappointments in the future.

1. Product Compensation Mechanism and Waiting Period

The primary compensation mechanism of cancer medical insurance includes per insured cancer limit and lifetime compensation limit, covering expenses related to cancer treatment such as diagnostic tests, hospital room and board, ward rounds fees, specialist fees, surgical and anaesthetic fees, operating theatre fees, medication costs, intensive care unit expenses, and more. These expenses must be for customary and reasonable treatment methods and must meet medical necessity.

Table 2: Comparison of 5 Semi-Private Room Cancer Medical Insurance Plans (HKD)
(Comparing premiums for a 35-year-old non-smoker)

Cancer Medical InsuranceCompensation LimitLifetime Compensation LimitMale
10-Year Average Annual Premium
Female
10-Year Average Annual Premium
AIA友邦
「癌症全方位保障2」
標準計劃
$1,000,000
(Reset every 3 years after cancer diagnosis)
$3,000,000$1,392$2,797
安盛
「癌症治療保障 II」
(標準)
$1,000,000
(Per cancer diagnosis)
$3,000,000$1,383$2,628
Bowtie
戰癌保 300
$1,000,000
(Reset every 3 years after cancer diagnosis)
$3,000,000$1,358$2,952
富衛
揀易保癌症保障計劃
(特等)
$1,000,000
(Per cancer diagnosis)
$3,000,000$1,534$3,333
宏利
癌症治療附加保障
-連住院及手術保障
$1,500,000
(Per cancer diagnosis)
$4,500,000$1,544$3,081

 Taking AIA's "Cancer Comprehensive Protection 2" as an example, the "Covered Cancer Limit" is HKD 1,000,000, while the lifetime cancer compensation limit is HKD 3,000,000.

Furthermore, if the insured person receives the first compensation and unfortunately faces a new cancer, persistent or spreading of the previous cancer, it is important to note the relevant waiting period. Compensation can only be claimed again after the waiting period has passed.

 

 

Table 3: Waiting Period for Second Cancer

ProductCancer Recurrence or SpreadCancer of Different Histopathology
友邦
「癌症全方位保障2」
標準計劃
Uses the same cancer limit,
reset every 3 years
Uses the same cancer limit,
reset every 3 years
安盛
「癌症治療保障 II」
(標準)/ (特級)
5 years1 year
Bowtie
戰癌保300
Uses the same cancer limit,
reset every 3 years
Uses the same cancer limit,
reset every 3 years
富衛
揀易保癌症保障計劃
(經濟)/(特等)
5 yearsUses new cancer limit
宏利
癌症治療附加保障-
連住院及手術保障
5 years1 year
Note: Cancer refers to insured cancer as defined by the respective insurance company.

2. Definition of Cancer

Cancer medical insurance policies often state on their websites or brochures that "not all types of cancer are covered." Even if coverage for malignant cancer and carcinoma in situ is mentioned, the exclusions or cancer definitions may specify that certain types of carcinoma in situ are not covered. Commonly excluded cancers or carcinoma in situ include "pre-cancerous tumours" and "cervical dysplasia CIN I and CIN II." Consumers are advised to consult their insurance broker or insurance company before purchasing a policy.

3. Ward Level and Covered Region

When purchasing cancer medical insurance, the ward level and coverage area are specified. If you wish to upgrade the ward level or seek treatment in the United States, the compensation limit is generally adjusted. For example, if a consumer opts for a semi-private ward plan with an annual compensation limit of HKD 1,000,000, the annual compensation limit will be reduced to 50% if they stay in a private ward or seek treatment in the United States.

4. Coverage for Extended Treatment

Cancer medical insurance often includes a wide range of extended treatments, commonly covering Chinese medicine treatment, dietitian consultations, physiotherapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, psychological counselling, home nursing, and medical equipment, among others. Policyholders should pay attention to the per-claim compensation limits and the number of covered sessions for these items. Certain plans may also cover psychological counselling (sometimes even for immediate family members) or expenses for wigs.

Some plans also include complementary therapies such as chiropractic treatment, aromatherapy, homeopathy, and art therapy. Additionally, there may be subsidies for transportation costs and expenses related to fertility preservation for cancer patients. Therefore, it is advisable to compare plans carefully before purchasing.

 

Note:
  1. The above premium information is updated as of 27 June 2022 and does not include the premium levy collected by the Insurance Authority.
  2. This article was last updated on: 27 June 2022.

This English version of this article has been generated by machine translation powered by AI. It is provided solely for reference purposes. In the event of any discrepancy or inconsistency between this translation and the original Chinese version, the Chinese version shall prevail.

10Life 編輯團隊

團隊成員由一群資料搜集員組成,主力保險相關資訊研究。

10Life 編輯團隊

團隊成員由一群資料搜集員組成,主力保險相關資訊研究。

Disclaimer

10Life 产品比较和 10Life 保险评分由获保监局授权持牌保险经纪公司 10Life Financial Limited(保监局牌照号码为FB1526)营运。10Life 产品比较和 10Life 保险评分是根据产品数据、事实陈述以及数据,并以一般消费者作为对象,从而作出数学运算,并不受与保险公司任何形式之合作或所获得之费用所影响。

10Life平台上之任何信息(「10Life信息」),包括但不限于产品比较、产品评分、网志文章等,旨在向香港特别行政区(「香港」)境内人士发布,所有信息及服务对象为于身处香港境内人士,仅供一般教育及参考用途。10Life信息无意,也不应被视为对任何保险、金融或投资产品进行受监管建议或专业建议、推荐、批准、认可、邀请或招揽。10Life信息并没有考虑阁下之个人需要,阅览有关数据也不应被视为正在进行个人合适性评估,且不足以构成任何购买保险产品决定的依据。购买任何保险产品或进行有关保险决定前,阁下应以保险公司提供的数据为准,自行进行研究,及/或寻求持牌保险中介人的独立及专业意见。10Life信息是以最大努力从不同渠道收集、验证、更新而成。10Life集团及其附属公司、关连人士、代理、董事、职员、员工将不会就有关资料引致的责任、索偿或损失负上任何责任,也概不保证或担保有关资料之准确性、完整性和适时性。

所显示保费数据尚未包括保险业监管局收取的保费征费,并均四舍五入至港元个位数。

如阁下对 10Life 产品比较和 10Life 保险评分有任何意见,欢迎电邮至 enquiries@10life.com

Whatsapp icon
Whatsapp icon
WeChat icon
WeChat icon
Enquiry icon Close icon
Back To Top
Whatsapp icon
Whatsapp icon
WhatsApp