false
Category
Author
Search for Articles
Trending Keywords
Category
Author
Search
Category
Author
Search
儲蓄與投資
編輯推介

Is savings insurance a scam? A roundup of the 4 major pitfalls and benefits of savings insurance

2025-08-21 5min read

When you search online for savings insurance, it’s not hard to find many netizens complaining that “returns aren’t as expected,” “you lose money if you surrender early,” and some even flatly call it a “savings insurance scam.” In fact, these situations are usually not because the product itself is flawed, but because people don’t have a sufficient understanding of how the policy works, its risks and limitations before buying, which leads to a gap between expectations and reality. To avoid being caught out, you should first learn about common savings-insurance pitfalls and then understand the benefits of savings insurance so you can make full use of it.

What is savings insurance?

If you want to know whether savings insurance is a rip-off, first understand its nature. Savings insurance is a type of insurance product that combines a savings function with life protection. Policyholders make regular payments (e.g., monthly, annually, or as a single lump sum), and the insurance company provides life coverage. When the policy matures, the policyholder can withdraw the cash value and receive the principal plus any corresponding interest; some products also offer additional bonuses or non-guaranteed returns. It is suitable for asset accumulation, retirement planning, a child’s education fund, or family wealth transfer. However, these products are relatively illiquid — if you surrender the policy early or stop paying premiums partway through, you may lose principal or returns.

Savings Insurance4Major Pitfalls Explained

Pitfall 1: The bonus-return misconception

Many people, upon seeing a policy's high projected total return, mistakenly believe that the bonuses are the actual cash they'll ultimately receive. In fact, bonuses in savings insurance are non-guaranteed and are affected by the insurer's investment performance, dividend policy, and overall market conditions. Even if the figures shown at point of sale are attractive, they are only projections and may not materialize. Before buying, it is advisable to refer to the "dividend realization rate" published by insurers as required by the Insurance Authority, to understand the historical gap between what insurers actually paid out and what they projected, and then judge whether the product is worth considering.

Pitfall 2: The risk of stopping premium payments

Savings insurance typically requires long-term regular premium payments, such as 5 years, 10 years or even 20 years. If the policyholder is unable to pay on time due to unemployment, financial difficulties or other emergencies, or completely stops paying, they may lose coverage. Insurers may initially cover unpaid premiums by using the policy's cash value, bonuses, or policy loans, but if the loan amount exceeds the policy's cash value the policy will be terminated — not only losing coverage but possibly forfeiting accumulated savings. Restoring a lapsed policy may also require re-underwriting... Therefore, it is recommended to assess your long-term ability to pay premiums before taking out a policy to ensure you can sustain the payments.

Pitfall 3: Insufficient liquidity

Savings insurance is not a readily accessible source of funds, especially not advisable to withdraw from in the early years. The principal needs to be locked in long term to allow compounding to work. Although some products permit withdrawal of bonuses, initial bonus amounts are limited; early withdrawals or partial surrenders can not only cause actual losses but also weaken future compound growth, affecting long-term returns.

Pitfall 4: Misleading sales

Some insurance salespeople overemphasize the "projected returns" of savings insurance while downplaying or failing to clearly explain the actual level of "guaranteed returns," causing policyholders to think the projected returns are the final returns. Before buying, distinguish between guaranteed and non-guaranteed returns, and set your premium amount according to your financial capacity to avoid a situation where "returns don't meet expectations."H2: Benefits of savings insurance
Although savings insurance has its limitations, it can still be a useful financial tool for some people. By understanding the product features and how to use it, you can make the most of its benefits.

Benefits of savings insurance

Although savings insurance has its limitations, it can still be a useful financial tool for some people. As long as you understand the product features and know how to use it, you can maximize its benefits.

Lower risk, with guaranteed returns

Compared with high-volatility investment products such as stocks and funds, savings insurance carries relatively lower risk and usually provides a guaranteed principal amount and steady growth,allowing assets to accumulate over time. You don't need to worry about interest rate changes or market volatility,making it especially suitable for conservative investors, or for those who want to allocate part of their funds for the medium to long term.

Low risk, guaranteed returns, helping assets grow steadily

Compared with highly volatile investment tools like stocks and funds, which can even result in a loss of principal, savings insurance is a low-risk option that generally offers a guaranteed amount. After paying premiums for a period and reaching the breakeven point, you can begin to accumulate wealth, with assets appreciating steadily over time and not affected by interest rate or market fluctuations—suitable for conservative investors. Experienced investors can also use savings insurance to diversify risk, which helps make overall investment returns more stable.

Flexible contribution methods to suit different life-stage needs

Many savings insurance plans offer different premium payment periods, such as5 years, 10 years or a single lump-sum payment, allowing policyholders to arrange contributions according to their personal budget and future plans. At the same time, many savings insurance plans also include thoughtful features to meet the needs of different life stages, such as offering multiple currency options so parents can prepare funds early for their children's overseas studies; or allowing accumulated bonuses to be locked in at specified times, adding an extra layer of protection to future returns and making financial plans more solid and secure.

Life insurance protection and wealth transfer

Savings insurance also provides basic life insurance protection; if the policyholder unfortunately dies, it can provide a lump-sum benefit to the family. The policy's cash value or bonuses can also serve as inheritance assets, and by designating beneficiaries it can avoid complicated probate procedures, simplifying the process of wealth distribution.

Hassle-free saving, cultivating financial discipline

Savings insurance requires regular contributions, which helps establish long-term saving habits. For those with less financial experience or who tend to spend their income quickly, this form of "forced savings" can help build assets and set aside funds for the future, such as retirement, children's education, or other major life expenses.

How should I choose a savings insurance plan?

There are many types of savings insurance plans on the market, with different coverage terms, return structures, and dividend distribution methods, and not every product suits everyone. Before choosing, you should first clarify your savings goals, contribution capacity, and liquidity needs, then compare policies based on guaranteed returns, expected cash value, and flexibility to find a plan that truly fits your needs and avoid falling into traps.If you want to know how to choose a savings insurance plan, feel free tocontact10Life’s insurance advisors to find the savings insurance product that suits you. 


Further reading

This English version of this article has been generated by machine translation powered by AI. It is provided solely for reference purposes. In the event of any discrepancy or inconsistency between this translation and the original Chinese version, the Chinese version shall prevail.

10Life 編輯團隊

團隊成員由一群資料搜集員組成,主力保險相關資訊研究。

10Life 編輯團隊

團隊成員由一群資料搜集員組成,主力保險相關資訊研究。

Disclaimer

10Life 产品比较和 10Life 保险评分由获保监局授权持牌保险经纪公司 10Life Financial Limited(保监局牌照号码为FB1526)营运。10Life 产品比较和 10Life 保险评分是根据产品数据、事实陈述以及数据,并以一般消费者作为对象,从而作出数学运算,并不受与保险公司任何形式之合作或所获得之费用所影响。

10Life平台上之任何信息(「10Life信息」),包括但不限于产品比较、产品评分、网志文章等,旨在向香港特别行政区(「香港」)境内人士发布,所有信息及服务对象为于身处香港境内人士,仅供一般教育及参考用途。10Life信息无意,也不应被视为对任何保险、金融或投资产品进行受监管建议或专业建议、推荐、批准、认可、邀请或招揽。10Life信息并没有考虑阁下之个人需要,阅览有关数据也不应被视为正在进行个人合适性评估,且不足以构成任何购买保险产品决定的依据。购买任何保险产品或进行有关保险决定前,阁下应以保险公司提供的数据为准,自行进行研究,及/或寻求持牌保险中介人的独立及专业意见。10Life信息是以最大努力从不同渠道收集、验证、更新而成。10Life集团及其附属公司、关连人士、代理、董事、职员、员工将不会就有关资料引致的责任、索偿或损失负上任何责任,也概不保证或担保有关资料之准确性、完整性和适时性。

所显示保费数据尚未包括保险业监管局收取的保费征费,并均四舍五入至港元个位数。

如阁下对 10Life 产品比较和 10Life 保险评分有任何意见,欢迎电邮至 enquiries@10life.com

Whatsapp icon
Whatsapp icon
WeChat icon
WeChat icon
Enquiry icon Close icon
Back To Top
Whatsapp icon
Whatsapp icon
WhatsApp