Enquiries: enquiries@10life.com
Hotline: (852) 3705 1599
Address: 16/F Greatmany Centre, 109-115 Queen’s Road East, Wan Chai, Hong Kong


Enquiries: enquiries@10life.com
Hotline: (852) 3705 1599
Address: 16/F Greatmany Centre, 109-115 Queen’s Road East, Wan Chai, Hong Kong



From 1 July 2025, the Insurance Authority has capped the illustrated customer internal rate of return (IRR) shown in the benefit illustrations for participating policies at the point of sale: 6% for Hong Kong dollar policies and 6.5% for non-Hong Kong dollar policies. In the past, agents have from time to time promoted participating products (such as savings insurance) as offering high returns, but these are expected returns, made up of guaranteed and non-guaranteed returns, and whether the latter materialise is uncertain. The cap on illustrated rates is aimed at overly aggressive return illustrations at the point of sale; it is not a cap on the policy’s actual return. So can insurers deliver the non-guaranteed returns originally illustrated? Before taking out a policy, consumers should understand the “dividend fulfilment ratios” (fulfilment ratios) published by insurers.
The dividend fulfilment ratio reflects an insurer’s past record in paying non-guaranteed benefits. The closer the ratio is to 100%, the more closely those non-guaranteed benefits have matched the insurer’s projections at the point of sale. The Insurance Authority requires insurers to update and disclose dividend fulfilment ratios no later than 30 June each year, publishing data for the previous reporting year. This article brings together 2025 reporting-year data for 16 insurers, first comparing each company’s overall average dividend fulfilment ratio, then explaining terminal dividends, annual dividends and reversionary bonuses in turn, to help readers understand fulfilment results and the limits of comparison.
What is a dividend fulfilment ratio, and how is it calculated?
Dividend fulfilment ratio = the total actual accumulated non-guaranteed benefits of the relevant policies ÷ the corresponding expected amount shown in the benefit illustration at the point of sale × 100%. The scope of the calculation differs by bonus type, so the ratio should not be treated as an investment return. For example, if the expected non-guaranteed benefits were HK$100,000 and HK$80,000 was actually paid, the dividend fulfilment ratio would be 80%. That means the relevant non-guaranteed benefits reached 80% of what was expected; it does not mean the investment return was 80%.
How should dividend fulfilment ratios be compared?
Look first at the company average, then at the bonus type. Insurers’ websites list the year-by-year dividend record of every participating policy, and the volume of data is hard for a typical reader to analyse. 10Life therefore calculates each insurer’s average dividend fulfilment ratio, and the share of data points with a ratio above 70%, to make the overall picture easier to grasp. When comparing, you should also pay attention to the number of data points; a company average should not be taken as the fulfilment ratio of an individual product.
Non-guaranteed benefits mainly fall into three types — annual dividends, terminal dividends and reversionary bonuses. Their payment timing, underlying investment strategy and capital requirements for the insurer differ markedly. Given that some participating policies on the market emphasise terminal dividends, while others are positioned around annual dividends, 10Life has further refined its scoring criteria and mechanism to set out dividend fulfilment ratios by bonus type, so that policyholders can match the figures to the bonus structure of the participating product they have in mind.
Comparison of insurers’ average dividend fulfilment ratios
The following sets out the overall average dividend fulfilment ratios of 16 insurers, the share of data points above 70%, and the number of data points. Note that each company’s mix of products, currencies, bonus types and policy years differs, so a company average should be treated only as a reference for past dividend results.
Table 1 Comparison of insurers’ average dividend fulfilment ratios 2025 reporting year
| Insurer | Average dividend fulfilment ratio | Share of data points above 70% | Number of data points |
| AIA | 93% | 94% | 397 |
| AXA | 96% | 95% | 315 |
| BOC Life | 92% | 99% | 157 |
| China Life | 81% | 74% | 339 |
| China Taiping Life (Hong Kong) | 99% | 100% | 47 |
| Chubb Life | 86% | 81% | 182 |
| CTF Life | 97% | 94% | 365 |
| FWD | 89% | 79% | 430 |
| Generali | 100% | 100% | 22 |
| Hang Seng Insurance | 97% | 78% | 251 |
| Hong Kong Life | 97% | 98% | 273 |
| HSBC Life | 95% | 92% | 210 |
| Manulife | 88% | 69% | 466 |
| Prudential | 78% | 59% | 462 |
| Sun Life | 90% | 83% | 134 |
| YF Life | 99% | 100% | 58 |
| Source: 2025 reporting-year data compiled by the 10Life research team. Averages are a simple average of each insurer’s valid data points and are not weighted by product sales or bonus amounts; the share above 70% uses that insurer’s number of data points as the denominator. Insurers are listed in alphabetical order of their English names; this is not a performance ranking. | |||
The average dividend fulfilment ratios of the companies listed in Table 1 range from 78% to 100%, but averages should be read together with the distribution of results and the number of data points. A company average does not represent the dividend performance of every product or policy year, and still less does it guarantee future returns. Policyholders should still refer to the dividend results of the three bonus types below, according to the bonus structure of the product they have in mind.
How should terminal dividend fulfilment ratios be read?
Insurers and insurance agents are currently promoting participating policies that mainly pay a terminal dividend, with the selling point of a substantial terminal dividend that rolls up over the long term. Insurers may also invest more in growth assets, such as equities, in pursuit of higher potential long-term returns.
A terminal dividend is a non-guaranteed bonus that the insurer pays in a lump sum when the policy ends (for example on death, surrender or maturity). The insurer sets out that year’s terminal dividend in the annual statement, but the amount declared each year is not the same: it is determined by investment performance, operating expenses and other factors, can rise or fall, and the actual amount is usually known only at the end.
Table 2 Comparison of terminal dividend fulfilment ratios 2025 reporting year
| Insurer | 2025 reporting year | ||
| Average dividend fulfilment ratio | Share of data points above 70% | Number of data points | |
| AIA | 98% | 97% | 126 |
| AXA | 97% | 94% | 162 |
| BOC Life | 91% | 100% | 44 |
| China Life | 100% | 100% | 26 |
| China Taiping Life (Hong Kong) | 99% | 100% | 16 |
| Chubb Life | 88% | 89% | 35 |
| CTF Life | 96% | 93% | 166 |
| FWD | 90% | 79% | 150 |
| Generali | 101% | 100% | 8 |
| Hang Seng Insurance | 124% | 100% | 91 |
| Hong Kong Life | 96% | 93% | 28 |
| HSBC Life | 103% | 100% | 88 |
| Manulife | 108% | 98% | 126 |
| Prudential | 75% | 46% | 243 |
| Sun Life | 85% | 61% | 28 |
| YF Life | 99% | 100% | 27 |
| Source: 2025 reporting-year data compiled by the 10Life research team. Insurers are listed in alphabetical order of their English names; this is not a performance ranking. | |||
The dividend fulfilment ratio for terminal dividends is calculated from the relevant data of policies that ended in that year; if there were no terminations in the year, there may be no data. The Insurance Authority requires participating product series that have issued new policies since 2010, and still had policies in force in the reporting year, to disclose their dividend fulfilment ratios. For long-term participating policies, the data now available still cannot fully reflect performance over 20 years, 30 years or longer.
Expected terminal dividends in the early policy years are usually smaller, so the fulfilment ratio may be close to or above 100%; that does not mean the same level can be maintained over the long term. When comparing, you should also look at results for longer policy years and avoid relying only on early-year data.
How should annual dividend fulfilment ratios be read?
In the past, insurers launched a number of participating policies built around annual dividends, so that policyholders could also receive bonuses steadily in the earlier policy years. An annual dividend, also called a cash dividend, is paid to the policyholder by the insurer each year, rather like a share dividend, and the amount already paid usually does not change. Depending on the policy terms, the policyholder may choose to withdraw the bonus or leave it in the policy account to accumulate interest. This type of bonus is more liquid: it is paid every year, and a withdrawal does not affect the policy’s guaranteed cash value.
Table 3 Comparison of annual dividend fulfilment ratios 2025 reporting year
| Insurer | 2025 reporting year | ||
| Average dividend fulfilment ratio | Share of data points above 70% | Number of data points | |
| AIA | 90% | 92% | 240 |
| AXA | 95% | 95% | 112 |
| BOC Life | 93% | 98% | 113 |
| China Life | 79% | 72% | 313 |
| China Taiping Life (Hong Kong) | 99% | 100% | 20 |
| Chubb Life | 84% | 78% | 135 |
| CTF Life | 97% | 94% | 159 |
| FWD | 88% | 80% | 280 |
| Generali | 100% | 100% | 14 |
| Hang Seng Insurance | 82% | 66% | 160 |
| Hong Kong Life | 97% | 98% | 245 |
| HSBC Life | 89% | 87% | 122 |
| Manulife | 81% | 59% | 340 |
| Prudential | 80% | 82% | 33 |
| Sun Life | 82% | 73% | 45 |
| YF Life | 99% | 100% | 28 |
| Source: 2025 reporting-year data compiled by the 10Life research team. Insurers are listed in alphabetical order of their English names; this is not a performance ranking. | |||
Even though participating policies that mainly feature annual dividends are becoming rarer, annual dividends are paid every year, so insurers must publish the related dividend fulfilment ratios each year, allowing policyholders to observe how consistently the insurer has paid bonuses. Table 3 has 2,359 annual dividend data points in total, more than for terminal dividends and reversionary bonuses; the listed company averages range from 79% to 100%. However, the number of data points and the product mix differ by insurer, so the figures should still be read together with the share of data points above 70%.
How should reversionary bonus fulfilment ratios be read?
In recent years some participating policies have paid a reversionary bonus (Reversionary Bonus), the amount of which is declared by the insurer each year. Once declared, its “face value” (Face Value) does not change: it is permanently added to the sum assured (Sum Assured) and is paid together with the death benefit. However, the cash value (Cash Value) of a reversionary bonus is generally still non-guaranteed, and on surrender it may be paid at a discounted value. Some products have different arrangements; for example, under Sun Life products, both the face value and the cash value of the reversionary bonus become guaranteed once declared.
Table 4 Comparison of reversionary bonus fulfilment ratios 2025 reporting year
Insurer | 2025 reporting year | ||
Average dividend | Share of data points | Number of | |
AIA | 94% | 100% | 31 |
AXA | 98% | 100% | 41 |
China Taiping Life (Hong Kong) | 100% | 100% | 11 |
Chubb Life | 100% | 100% | 12 |
CTF Life | 100% | 100% | 40 |
Prudential | 83% | 73% | 186 |
Sun Life | 99% | 100% | 61 |
YF Life | 100% | 100% | 3 |
| Source: 2025 reporting-year data compiled by the 10Life research team. Table 4 lists only the eight insurers with reversionary bonus data, in alphabetical order of their English names; this is not a performance ranking. The remaining insurers have zero relevant data points and are not shown. | |||
The products and accumulation periods involved in reversionary bonuses differ from those of other bonus types. Table 4 has 385 data points in total, from the eight insurers with relevant data; those eight companies’ average reversionary bonus fulfilment ratios range from 83% to 100%.
Why do the dividend fulfilment ratios of terminal, annual and reversionary bonuses differ?
The dividend fulfilment ratios of the three bonus types above are affected by the characteristics of each bonus, the product structure and the policy year. You should not conclude from the average of one bonus type alone that that type of product offers a better overall return.
Starting with terminal dividends, the insurer pays them in a lump sum when the policy ends, and the terminal dividend on a savings policy usually rolls up over time. By comparison, the expected terminal dividend in the early policy years is not particularly large; the public data now available still do not fully cover 20-year, 30-year or longer holding periods, and may not represent the long-term picture.
As for reversionary bonuses, once the insurer has declared a bonus, its face value is permanently added to the policy’s sum assured and is paid on the insured person’s death; but its cash value is generally still non-guaranteed, and on surrender it may be paid at a discounted value. Some products are an exception: for example, under Sun Life, both the face value and the cash value of the reversionary bonus become guaranteed once declared, so the related cash value is not discounted on surrender.
By contrast, annual dividends are paid every year, and once declared they are “guaranteed”. That means the insurer must hold more sufficient stable assets to meet this expectation, so the underlying investments usually lean towards more conservative assets such as bonds. Because the insurer must continue to pay a bonus to all policyholders every year, it is harder to maintain a satisfactory annual dividend fulfilment ratio over the long term.
When comparing savings insurance, consumers should first understand the product’s bonus structure and positioning, then “match like with like” and refer to the dividend fulfilment ratio results of similar products from that insurer.
Unsure which type of bonus your savings policy belongs to, or which set of dividend fulfilment ratios you should use as a reference? You are welcome to ask a 10Life adviser on WhatsApp about the points to watch when comparing.


Frequently asked questions on dividend fulfilment ratios
No. A 100% dividend fulfilment ratio only means that the amount of the relevant non-guaranteed benefits actually paid matched what was illustrated at the point of sale; a ratio above 100% means payments exceeded the original expectation, and a ratio below 100% means they fell short. These figures reflect past performance; they do not mean that bonuses or future total returns are guaranteed.
The 10Life research team has compiled 2025 reporting-year data covering 16 insurers and 4,108 valid data points in total, including 1,364 for terminal dividends, 2,359 for annual dividends and 385 for reversionary bonuses. This is the total number of data points within the scope of this comparison, not the total number of policies in Hong Kong or the market as a whole; a data point is also not the same as a policy count.
This article uses data for all policy years and takes a simple average of valid data points, without weighting by product sales, policy count or the amount of bonuses actually paid. One data point corresponds to one product, one currency, one bonus type, one policy year and one reporting year. The actual breakdown by product, currency and policy year depends on how the insurer reported the figures; some data may be disclosed on a combined basis by product series, currency or year group.
The average summarises the overall level of dividend fulfilment ratios, but it can be affected by individual extreme data points. This article presents the simple average and, in addition, the share of valid data points with a dividend fulfilment ratio above 70%, to give further information on the distribution and to help readers assess how stable the ratios have been.
Regulators require insurers to disclose dividend fulfilment ratios so that consumers can see their past record in paying non-guaranteed benefits, as a reference. Under the Insurance Authority’s disclosure scope, participating product series that have issued new policies since 2010 and still had policies in force in the reporting year must disclose data. The first 10 policy years must be shown year by year, and policy years beyond 10 years are disclosed on a combined basis; not every company therefore presents year-by-year data for all longer durations. These disclosures may not fully reflect a product’s long-term dividend performance. 10Life organises the averages at insurer level to help readers see the overall picture; when comparing an individual product, you should still refer to the data for that product series and the corresponding policy years.
The dividend fulfilment ratio only reflects how the “non-guaranteed return” actually paid compares with what was illustrated at the point of sale; it is not itself a total investment return. The total return of a participating policy is made up of “guaranteed return” and “non-guaranteed return”. Because the insurer must pay the guaranteed benefits in accordance with the terms (unless the insurer is insolvent), even if the non-guaranteed return falls short of the originally illustrated figure, the gap in the overall return still depends on the mix of guaranteed and non-guaranteed parts.
For example, if a product has a very high share of “guaranteed return”, it may still deliver a satisfactory total rate of return even if its dividend fulfilment ratio is not impressive. Consumers should therefore pay attention to the mix of guaranteed and non-guaranteed benefits in a participating product, and refer to both the dividend fulfilment ratio and the total rate of return.
The fulfilment ratio only reflects past data, and past data cannot predict the future; they should be used as a reference only. An insurer’s actual dividend results are affected by market fluctuations, the company’s investment performance and the policy’s dividend policy.
You can look it up on the insurer’s official website, or use the Insurance Authority’s list of insurer dividend fulfilment ratio web pages to find the relevant disclosures. When reviewing the figures, you should match the product series, policy currency, bonus type, policy year and reporting year, and refer to products with similar features.
Insurance Authority dividend fulfilment ratio page
Dividend fulfilment ratios are based on the data insurers currently disclose, but the scope of disclosure and the way the figures are presented still have limitations, which lead to the following constraints:
Participating products involve different currencies and bonus types, and the way the figures are presented is complex and hard for the public to interpret. The 10Life actuarial team therefore uses a consistent standard to bring together a large volume of data and score each insurer, and also considers an experience factor, awarding a “stable dividend fulfilment ratio insurer” rating to companies that outperform the market, so that consumers can understand the results more easily. The tables in this article are arranged by English name, not by that rating.
An insurer’s dividend fulfilment score depends on the following factors:
When calculating an insurer’s dividend fulfilment score, 10Life takes into account all dividend fulfilment ratio data published by the insurer, calculates that company’s average and the share of data points with a ratio above 70%, and identifies insurers whose average fulfilment ratio is better than the market and whose results have also been stable.
Insurers differ in how long they have operated in Hong Kong and in their experience. For insurers with few dividend fulfilment ratio data points, 10Life applies different adjustment factors to adjust for the effect of the experience factor on the insurer’s dividend results.
10Life’s research and scoring of dividend fulfilment ratios is intended to improve transparency and to educate the public. We do not receive payment for it, and we do not favour any insurer because of a commercial relationship. As always, 10Life also publishes the scoring method so that the public can study and discuss it.
Conclusion: when comparing dividend fulfilment ratios, look at both the bonus structure and the distribution of the data
10Life gathers market information and compiles and analyses insurers’ dividend fulfilment ratios, to improve the transparency of participating products. In the process, we have found that the information now available still has shortcomings. 10Life will recommend that the regulator and insurers strengthen disclosure, in the hope of further refining the scoring criteria and providing more precise and in-depth analysis in future. 10Life also welcomes suggestions from the industry and from consumers, so that we can together improve insurance transparency and strengthen public confidence in insurance.
Want to understand the bonus structure of a savings policy you have in mind, or what dividend fulfilment ratios may mean for your choice? You are welcome to contact a 10Life adviser on WhatsApp to review and compare protection and savings options according to your needs.
WhatsApp us about participating and savings insurance
Notes:
1. Tables 1 to 4 all use 2025 reporting-year data only. Tables 1 to 3 cover the 16 insurers provided by the research team; Table 4 lists only the eight insurers with reversionary bonus data.
2. Averages and the share of data points above 70% are calculated from unrounded original values and then rounded to the nearest whole-number percentage; “above 70%” does not include values equal to 70%.
3. The research information above is provided by 10Life.
This English version of this article has been generated by machine translation powered by AI. It is provided solely for reference purposes. In the event of any discrepancy or inconsistency between this translation and the original Chinese version, the Chinese version shall prevail.

Our team of professional content researchers focussing on insurance

Our team of professional content researchers focussing on insurance
10Life Product Comparison and 10Life Insurance Ratings are developed by 10Life Financial Limited, an authorised insurance broker company licensed with the Insurance Authority under License Number FB1526. 10Life Product Comparison and 10Life Insurance Ratings are developed for generic customer segments using mathematical calculations based on product information, facts and data, and are not influenced by any partnerships with or fees received from insurance companies. Any information on 10Life Platform ("10Life Information"), including but not limited to Product Comparison, Product Ratings, Blog Articles are intended for general education purpose and reference only. None of the 10Life Information is intended, nor should they be considered or relied upon, as regulated advice, insurance, financial, investment or professional advice, recommendation, approval, endorsement, invitation or solicitation in respect of any insurance, financial or investment products. 10Life Information does not take into account your individual needs. Reading 10Life Information should not be considered as conducting a suitability assessment, and is not sufficient to form the basis of any decisions to purchase any insurance products. You should rely on information authorised by insurance companies, carry out your own research and/or seek independent advice from licensed intermediaries before purchasing any insurance products or making any insurance decisions. While reasonable effort is used when collecting, validating and updating 10Life Information from various channels, none of 10Life Group and its subsidiaries, affiliates, agents, directors, officers and employees will be responsible for any liability, claim or loss arising from or associated with you using 10Life Information. No warranty, representation or guarantee is given by 10Life Group and its subsidiaries on the accuracy, completeness and timeliness of the information. If you have any questions on 10Life Product Comparison and 10Life Insurance Ratings, please email us at enquiries@10life.com



